Digital Equity and Inclusion Gaps in Municipal Digital Transformation: A Systematic Review of Global South Evidence

Edem Lekettey; Asep Muftahudin

doi:10.24198/jmpp.v10i2.69886

Digital Equity and Inclusion Gaps in Municipal Digital Transformation: A Systematic Review of Global South Evidence

Edem Lekettey, Asep Muftahudin

Abstrak

Municipal digital transformation is increasingly promoted as a pathway for improving public service delivery, administrative efficiency, and citizen participation across cities in the Global South. However, emerging evidence suggests that digitally mediated governance systems frequently generate uneven inclusion outcomes due to variations in institutional capacity, governance arrangements, and sociotechnological inequalities. This study examines how municipal digital transformation shapes digital equity and inclusion outcomes. Through an interpretive thematic synthesis of 57 Scopus-indexed empirical studies, we construct a governance-focused typology conceptualizing municipalities as service providers, platform orchestrators, data stewards, inclusion enablers, and institutional capacity builders within digitally mediated governance systems. Our results indicate that digital inequities emerge not only from access-related issues but also from weak institutional responsiveness, digital governance fragmentation, reliance on platforms, exclusionary service provision, and inconsistent participation. The findings contribute to the literature on digital governance in municipalities, advancing knowledge about digital equality as institutionally and governance-enabled rather than technologically determined. Finally, we highlight the importance of institutional capacity strengthening, inclusive digital governance, and responsible digital platforms to enable public value creation globally, especially in the Global South.

Kata Kunci

Municipal Digital Transformation; Digital Equity and Inclusion; Local Government Governance; Public Service Delivery; Global South

Teks Lengkap:

PDF (English)

Referensi

Afinowi, T. (2025). Sustainable urban management through digital transformation and technologies in the South: Challenges and prospects. OIDA International Journal of Sustainable Development, 18(08), 79–98.

Aldehim, G., khan, S., Shahzad, T., Khan, M. A., Ghadi, Y. Y., Jiang, W., Mazhar, T., & Hamam, H. (2025). Balancing sustainability and security: A review of 5G and IoT in smart cities. Digital Communications and Networks, 11(6), 1722–1737. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dcan.2025.06.007

Aldhi, I. F., Suhariadi, F., Rahmawati, E., Supriharyanti, E., Hardaningtyas, D., Sugiarti, R., & Abbas, A. (2025). Bridging Digital Gaps in Smart City Governance: The Mediating Role of Managerial Digital Readiness and the Moderating Role of Digital Leadership. Smart Cities, 8(4), 117. https://doi.org/10.3390/smartcities8040117

Amnesti, S. K. W., Zulaichah, S., & Istiqomah, N. (2024). Legal protection of personal data security in Indonesian Local Government apps: Al Farabi’s perspective. Legality : Jurnal Ilmiah Hukum, 33(1), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.22219/ljih.v33i1.34623

Anggraini, R. I., Maarif, M. S., Asikin, Z., & Sukmawati, A. (2025). Enhancing The Performance of Community-Based MSMEs Through Multi-Actor Ecosystem Governance: Evidence from MACTOR Analysis. International Journal of Accounting and Economics Studies, 12(4), 74–83. https://doi.org/10.14419/2tkhne27

Barrutia, J. M., Echebarria, C., Aguado-Moralejo, I., Apaolaza-Ibáñez, V., & Hartmann, P. (2022). Leading smart city projects: Government dynamic capabilities and public value creation. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 179, 121679. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2022.121679

Berniker, T., & Humphreys, L. (2024). Surveillance Working Groups as Geomedia Governance. Media and Communication, 12. https://doi.org/10.17645/mac.8201

Booth, A., Sommer, I., Noyes, J., Houghton, C., & Campbell, F. (2024). Rapid reviews methods series: guidance on rapid qualitative evidence synthesis. BMJ Evidence-Based Medicine, 29(3), 194–200. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjebm-2023-112620

Cao, X., & Sun, P. (2025). Creating the beta-infrastructure: Facial recognition terminals and social management during and after COVID-19 in China. New Media & Society, 27(9), 5220–5238. https://doi.org/10.1177/14614448241250033

Castellanos, S., Wright, K., & Grant-Muller, S. (2025). Governing shared mobility: a comparison of the public policy goals being pursued in three cities. Transportation, 52(4), 1429–1456. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11116-023-10461-6

Chakiri, H., El Mohajir, M., & Assem, N. (2020). A data warehouse hybrid design framework using domain ontologies for local good-governance assessment. Transforming Government: People, Process and Policy, 14(2), 171–203. https://doi.org/10.1108/TG-04-2019-0025

Chen, X., & Jiang, H. (2025). Bridging trust through institution and process: how does digital government increase citizens’ trust in local government? Public Management Review, 1–26. https://doi.org/10.1080/14719037.2025.2605469

Czemiel-Grzybowska, W., Pavlakova-Docekalova, M., Ratajczak-Mrozek, M., & Thompson, C. (2024). Sustainable development of smart cities through municipal waste incinerators: the examples of artificial intelligence in technological entrepreneurship. Engineering Management in Production and Services, 16(4), 127–138. https://doi.org/10.2478/emj-2024-0037

Datta, A. (2023). The digitalising state: Governing digitalisation-as-urbanisation in the global south. Progress in Human Geography, 47(1), 141–159. https://doi.org/10.1177/03091325221141798

Dong, Y., Qi, C., Gui, C., & Yang, Y. (2025). Spatial Spillover Effects of Digital Infrastructure on Food System Resilience: An Analysis Incorporating Threshold Effects and Spatial Decay Boundaries. Foods, 14(9), 1484. https://doi.org/10.3390/foods14091484

Eom, S.-J., & Lee, J. (2022). Digital government transformation in turbulent times: Responses, challenges, and future direction. Government Information Quarterly, 39(2), 101690. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.giq.2022.101690

Feng, L., Zhang, L., Wang, J., & Feng, J. (2024). How to promote the participation of enterprises using open government data? Evolutionary game analysis by applying dynamic measures. Expert Systems with Applications, 238, 122348. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eswa.2023.122348

Ferza, R., & Lee, D. S. (2026). Online Accessibility of Local Public Enterprise Financial Statements in Indonesia: Can it be Predicted by Institutional Traits of Parent Local Governments? Public Administration and Development, 46(1), 7–20. https://doi.org/10.1002/pad.70025

Flemming, K., & Noyes, J. (2021). Qualitative Evidence Synthesis: Where Are We at? International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 20. https://doi.org/10.1177/1609406921993276

Galushi, L. T., & Malatji, T. L. (2022). Digital Public Administration and Inclusive Governance at the South African Local Government, in Depth Analysis of E-Government and Service Delivery in Musina Local Municipality. Academic Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies, 11(6), 116. https://doi.org/10.36941/ajis-2022-0154

Greavu-Şerban, V., Gheorghiu, A., & Ungureanu, C. (2025). A multidimensional perspective of digitization in Romanian public institutions. World Development, 191, 106996. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2025.106996

Grossi, G., & Welinder, O. (2024). Smart cities at the intersection of public governance paradigms for sustainability. Urban Studies, 61(10), 2011–2023. https://doi.org/10.1177/00420980241227807

Guenduez, A. A., & Mergel, I. (2022). The role of dynamic managerial capabilities and organizational readiness in smart city transformation. Cities, 129, 103791. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2022.103791

Hairudin, A. R., Che Ani, A. I., Saiful Bahri, M. A., Abdul Maulud, K. N., & Rahman, M. A. (2025). WebGIS for Urban Building Management: A Case Study of Petaling Jaya City. PaperASIA, 41(1b), 441–448. https://doi.org/10.59953/paperasia.v41i1b.196

He, B. (2026). Incentivizing paths for implementation of accessibility guidelines on Chinese municipal e-government websites: a qualitative comparative analysis. Universal Access in the Information Society, 25(2), 34. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10209-025-01299-z

Heeks, R. (2022). Digital inequality beyond the digital divide: conceptualizing adverse digital incorporation in the global South. Information Technology for Development, 28(4), 688–704. https://doi.org/10.1080/02681102.2022.2068492

Ito, H., & Kato, K. (2025). From corporate control to participatory governance: Revisiting the Integrative Smart Technology Model through Toyota’s Woven City. Journal of Urban Affairs, 1–17. https://doi.org/10.1080/07352166.2025.2580308

Jibladze, M., Manvelidze, I., Zoidze, I., & Phartenadze, G. (2024). E-governance under the framework of open governance in Georgia: current situation, problems and opportunities. Public Administration and Policy, 27(2), 193–205. https://doi.org/10.1108/PAP-05-2023-0074

Jieutsa, L., Gbaguidi, I., Nadifi, W., & Koseki, S. (2024). Deployment of digital technologies in African cities: emerging issues and policy recommendations for local governments. Data & Policy, 6, e21. https://doi.org/10.1017/dap.2024.7

Jonek-Kowalska, I. (2025). Dimensions of Urban Social Sustainability: A Study Based on Polish Cities. Sustainability, 17(19), 8615. https://doi.org/10.3390/su17198615

Kozaman Aygün, S., & İnal Çekiç, T. (2025). Sustainable Urban Governance and the Digital Divide: Patterns of E-Participation in Istanbul. Sustainability, 17(11), 4913. https://doi.org/10.3390/su17114913

Mangai, M. S., & Ayodele, A. A. (2025). Reimagining Public Service Delivery: Digitalising Initiatives for Accountability and Efficiency. Administrative Sciences, 15(12), 477. https://doi.org/10.3390/admsci15120477

Mills, D., Pudney, S., Pevcin, P., & Dvorak, J. (2021). Evidence-Based Public Policy Decision-Making in Smart Cities: Does Extant Theory Support Achievement of City Sustainability Objectives? Sustainability, 14(1), 3. https://doi.org/10.3390/su14010003

Mora, L., Gerli, P., Ardito, L., & Messeni Petruzzelli, A. (2023). Smart city governance from an innovation management perspective: Theoretical framing, review of current practices, and future research agenda. Technovation, 123, 102717. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.technovation.2023.102717

Mullick, M., & Patnaik, A. (2025). Negotiating urban entities: marginalized citizens, participation, and the Indian smart city. International Journal of Urban Sciences, 29(sup1), 136–156. https://doi.org/10.1080/12265934.2024.2358102

Nematollahi, H. R., Mohammadi, H., Gholipour, A., & Mohammad Esmaeili, N. (2024). Strengthening human resource management system with digital practices, transformation, and task interdependence. International Journal of Human Capital in Urban Management, 9(4), 579–600.

Perng, S.-Y. (2025). Inclusion by design, exclusion in practice: Politics of inclusion in innovating future mobility systems in Taipei’s living lab. Journal of Transport Geography, 128, 104313. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2025.104313

Radu, L.-D., & Popescul, D. (2023). The role of data platforms in COVID-19 crisis: a smart city perspective. Aslib Journal of Information Management, 75(6), 1033–1055. https://doi.org/10.1108/AJIM-01-2022-0032

Rahman, K. M. A., & Zhang, D. (2018). Analyzing the Level of Accessibility of Public Urban Green Spaces to Different Socially Vulnerable Groups of People. Sustainability, 10(11), 3917. https://doi.org/10.3390/su10113917

Ranchod, R. (2020). The data-technology nexus in South African secondary cities: The challenges to smart governance. Urban Studies, 57(16), 3281–3298. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042098019896974

Ricker, B., Cinnamon, J., & Dierwechter, Y. (2020). When open data and data activism meet: An analysis of civic participation in Cape Town, South Africa. Canadian Geographies / Géographies Canadiennes, 64(3), 359–373. https://doi.org/10.1111/cag.12608

Sadat, A. (2025). Digital governance and civic inclusion to enhance public participation in political decision-making processes. Frontiers in Political Science, 7. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpos.2025.1671373

Santos, I. G., Tuzzo, S. A., Borges, F., & Sá, M. M. (2025). From Technology to Social Inclusion: Citizens’ Perceptions and Priorities About Smart Cities in the District of Porto, Portugal. Sustainability, 17(18), 8484. https://doi.org/10.3390/su17188484

Shayan, S., & Kim, K. P. (2025). Social Responses and Change Management Strategies in Smart City Transitions: A Socio-Demographic Perspective. Smart Cities, 8(6), 188. https://doi.org/10.3390/smartcities8060188

Sigurjonsson, T. O., Jónsson, E., & Gudmundsdottir, S. (2024). Sustainability of Digital Initiatives in Public Services in Digital Transformation of Local Government: Insights and Implications. Sustainability, 16(24), 10827. https://doi.org/10.3390/su162410827

Sucupira Furtado, L., da Silva, T. L. C., Ferreira, M. G. F., de Macedo, J. A. F., & de Melo Lima Cavalcanti Moreira, J. K. (2023). A framework for Digital Transformation towards Smart Governance: using big data tools to target SDGs in Ceará, Brazil. Journal of Urban Management, 12(1), 74–87. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jum.2023.01.003

Sun, K., Liu, N., Sun, X., & Zhang, Y. (2023). Design and implementation of big data analysis and visualisation platform for the smart city. International Journal of Information Technology and Management, 22(3/4), 373–385. https://doi.org/10.1504/IJITM.2023.131842

Thomas, J., & Harden, A. (2008). Methods for the thematic synthesis of qualitative research in systematic reviews. BMC Medical Research Methodology, 8(1), 45. https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2288-8-45

Xia, Y., Li, B., Yang, J., Guo, W., Sun, J., Zeng, X., & Zheng, J. (2025). Sustainable service quality assessment of Chinese healthcare e-government: a multi-criteria decision framework based on SERVQUAL model and entropy-weight TOPSIS method. Frontiers in Digital Health, 7. https://doi.org/10.3389/fdgth.2025.1611979

Yang, X., Shen, A., Han, Y., & Cao, D. (2019). Promoting Equitable Quality of Early Childhood Education in Rural and Urban China: A Case Study of Rural-Urban Continuum Model / Promicanje pravedne raspodjele kvalitetnog odgoja i obrazovanja u ranom djetinjstvu u ruralnim i urbanim područjima u Kini: st. Croatian Journal of Education - Hrvatski Časopis Za Odgoj i Obrazovanje, 20. https://doi.org/10.15516/cje.v20i0.3039

Yang, Y., & Lin, G. T. R. (2025). Local Digital Economic Growth, Enterprise Digital Transformation, and Digital Dividends: Evidence from China. Systems, 13(4), 297. https://doi.org/10.3390/systems13040297

Younus, M., Purnomo, E. P., Nurmandi, A., Mutiarin, D., Manaf, H. A., Mumtaz, F., & Khairunnisa, T. (2025). Analyzing the trend of government support for cloud computing usage in e-government architecture. Journal of Cloud Computing, 14(1), 14. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13677-025-00735-y

Zhang, C., Wu, S., Dong, Y., & Jiang, M. (2025). Government-Led Digital Governance and the Digital Divide Among Cities: Implications for Sustainable Digital Transformation in China. Sustainability, 17(23), 10700. https://doi.org/10.3390/su172310700

Zheng, Y., & Walsham, G. (2021). Inequality of what? An intersectional approach to digital inequality under Covid-19. Information and Organization, 31(1), 100341. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.infoandorg.2021.100341

DOI: https://doi.org/10.24198/jmpp.v10i2.69886